Lightning Rods
Benjamin Franklin got us all thinking about the protection of buildings from
lightning with lightning rods. Lightning strikes were quite a problem even in
his day. Here with more.
|
|
History and Mystery of Lightning
Science investigates the known, the unknown, and
unknowable. Today, lightning research is divided into
various disciplines, some of which are:
 |
Atmospheric Physics and Electrostatics.
 |
Electrical Engineering.
 |
Climatology, including thunderstorm morphology
& dynamics.
 |
Meteorology and other sub-sectors.
|
| | |
These detailed technical examinations may never
provide all the answers about lightning, but modern
investigation techniques are busy providing new
information.
There was another earlier time when lightning was
the magic fire from the sky which man captured and used
to keep warm at night . It kept the savage animals away.
As primitive man sought answers about the natural world,
lightning became a part of his superstitions, his myths
and his early religions.
Early Greeks believed that lightning was a weapon of
Zeus. Thunderbolts were invented by Minerva the goddess
of wisdom. Since lightning was a manifestation of the
gods, any spot struck by lightning was regarded as
sacred. Greek and Roman temples often were erected at
these sites, where the gods were worshipped in an
attempt to appease them. The Moslems also attributed
lightning and thunder to their god. The Koran says
"He it is who showeth you lightning and launches
the thunderbolts."
Scandinavian mythology alludes to Thor, the
thunderer, who was the foe of all demons. Thor tossed
lightning bolts at his enemies. Thor also gave us
Thurs-day.
In the pantheistic Hindu religion, Indra was the god
of heaven, lightning, rain, storms and thunder. The
Maruts used the thunderbolts as weapons. Umpundulo is
the lightning bird-god of the Bantu tribesmen in Africa.
Even today their medicine men go out in storms and bid
the lightning to strike far away.
The Navajo Indians hold that lightning has great
power in their healing rituals. Sand paintings show the
lightning bolt as a wink in the Thunderbird's eye.
Lightning is associated with wind, rain and crop growth.
As late as the early 1800s in Russia, when rain was
wanted, three men climbed a tree. One would knock two
firebrands together; the sparks imitating lightning.
Another one would pour water over twigs, imitating rain.
A third would bang on a kettle to attract the thunder.
And throughout early Europe, church bell ringers would
make as much noise as possible, hoping to scare away the
storms from these holy dwellings which were struck
frequently by lightning.
During the Napoleonic wars, more than 220 British
tall ships were damaged--not by the French, but by
lightning. The solution, of course, was to install
lightning rods. But since that device had been invented
by a "rebel colonist" named Benjamin Franklin,
His Majesty's Navy steadfastly refused. It took until
the 1830's before the admiralty finally saw the light
and forgot about old colonial rebellions.
Even Santa Klaus gets into the act with his reindeer
Donner (thunder) and Blitzen (lightning).
Early superstitions were observed as Cause and
Effect, which now has been fancified as science.
Socrates said, "that's not Zeus up there, it's a
vortex of air." Genghis Kahn forbade his subjects
from washing garments or bathing in running water during
a storm. Thales, the Greek philosopher, in 600 BC,
rubbed a piece of amber with a dry cloth and noted that
it would then attract feathers and straw. William
Gilbert, court healer to Queen Elizabeth, in the late
1500s, also used amber to duplicate the earlier
experiments. He named this via electrica, after electra
which is Greek for amber. He didn't know it, but he was
demonstrating static electricity.
Lightning is a big spark...static electricity on a
giant scale. Machines for creating static electricity
were invented...the Leyden jar was like a thermos bottle
which stored volts. Friction machines could charge the
jars and electricity could be carried around and
demonstrated. "Electric magic" was in great
demand at the royal courts of Europe as entertainment.
The parlor tricks amused and fascinated people.
Science was in its infancy during these times. Sir
Isaac Newton had proposed that basic mathematical laws
were the foundation for understanding the forces of
nature. With "electric magic" there was
insufficient experimental investigation to explain its
behavior. In 1746, Dr. Spence from Scotland came to
Philadelphia. He there demonstrated some "electric
magic" to an audience which included the local
postmaster.
That man was Benjamin Franklin. Franklin was
curiosity personified. At age eight he left the Boston
Grammar School, ending his formal studies. He was
endowed with a strong sense of investigation and
self-discipline. He learned and studied things all his
life. He invented the bifocal glasses and the Franklin
stove. An expert swimmer, a vegetarian, multi-lingual,
and a word-smith publisher, his Poor Richard's Almanac
was selling 10,000 copies a year in the colonies. Even
today some of those aphorisms about thrift and hard work
are valuable to recall:
Honesty is the best policy. He who drinketh fast,
payeth slow. Sloth maketh all things difficult, but
Industry all easy.
At age 42, Franklin sold his Philadelphia printing
business for half the profits for 20 years. He retired.
He involved himself in social experiments like the
American Revolutionary War and the Declaration of
Independence. He dabbled with the electric Leyden Jar
and pondered questions..."how many small jars would
kill a chicken? How many large jars for a turkey? Why
did an electrocuted turkey taste better than a
conventionally-killed bird? What is lightning? Why is it
burning down churches? Can it be captured to a Leyden
jar? Can it be captured to earth safely?..." Then
came the kites and keys experiments in 1752-53 and
Franklin's deduction that lightning was, afterall,
electricity.
This was followed by his lightning rod invention and
its duplication in France and usefulness throughout
Europe. Franklin was a celebrated figure in his time.
Franklin has been called America's patron saint of
common sense. Perhaps, had he not been close to the
French Royal Court, and been able to influence France to
finance the American Revolutionary War, all of us here
in the USA today might be speaking with English accents!
Recently some scientists have concluded that
lightning may have played a part in the evolution of
living organisms. Nobel prize winning chemist Harold
Urey proposed that the earth's early atmosphere
consisted of ammonia, hydrogen, methane, and water
vapor. One of his students, Stanley Miller, used an
electric spark to duplicate lightning and introduced it
into the chemical brew. He was careful to excluded any
living organisms from the experiment. At the end of a
week, he examined the mixture and found it contained
newly-formed amino acids, the very building blocks of
protein. Did lightning play a role in creating life
itself? Science now is pushing the envelope of
lightning's secrets. More has been learned about this
transient phenomenon in the past 3-4 years than in the
preceding two hundred forty four years since Franklin's
"kites and keys" experiments. Stay tuned...

Most of the above was adapted from Viemeister, P.:
1961, The Lightning Book, MIT Press, Cambridge MA.
(Worth buying your own copy.) See also Martin Uman's
several books on lightning from an introductory physics
perspective.
This factsheet courtesy the
National Lightning Safety Institute, Louisville, CO.
Tel. 303-666-8817. WWWeb = http://www.lightningsafety.com
|

|
|
`
Lightning rod
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.
A lightning rod (or lightning protector) is a metal
strip or rod, usually of copper
or similar conductive
material, used as part of lightning
safety to protect tall or isolated structures (such as the roof of a
building or the mast of a vessel) from lightning
damage. Its formal name is lightning finial. Sometimes, the system is
informally refered to as:
 |
a lightning conductor,
 |
a lightning arrester, or
 |
a lightning discharger.
|
| |
However, these terms actually refer to lightning protection systems in
general or specific components within them.
Lightning rod dissipators make a structure
less attractive by which charges can flow to the air
around it. This then reduces the voltage
between the point and the storm cloud,
making a strike less likely. The most common charge dissipators appear as
slightly-blunted metal spikes sticking out in all directions from a metal
ball. These are mounted on short metal arms at the very top of a radio
antenna or tower,
the area by far most likely to be struck. These devices reduce, but do not
eliminate, the risk of lightning strikes.
Arrestors
A lightning arrestor is a device
that shunts
or diverts the massive voltage
and electrical
current of a lighting
strike to an earthed ground.
Electrical equipment can be protected from lightning by an arrester, a device
that contains one or more gas-filled spark gaps between the equipment's cables
and earth. An arrester is designed to handle much higher jolts of electricity
than a surge
protector, which cannot handle a direct strike at all.
Should lightning strike a building, the current will travel through the
conductor rather than through the fabric of the building, causing less damage.
Should lightning strike one of the cables, the high voltage will cause the gas
in the spark gap to break down and become a conductor, providing a path for
the lightning to reach the ground without passing through the equipment. It
typically involves a spark
gap, across which a normal voltage cannot arc.
When lightning exceeds the arrestor's breakdown
voltage, the currents arcs to the ground and prevents arcing around inside
sensitive
electronic
equipment
connected further downline. The spark gap may be filled with a noble
gas, or with air.
Other types may work by blocking normal alternating
current (AC), but allowing the direct
current (DC) from a lightning discharge.
Lightning arrestors are typically installed on electric
power transmission lines, and on radio
tower feedlines
between the radio
antenna and transmitter.
Smaller ones can also be installed on the mains
electricity service coming into a building (even a home), just before the circuit
breaker panel. Telephone
wires also have fusible
links sometimes where they enter a building, connected by carbon
which will vaporize
with very high current.
Construction and uses
A lightning rod is connected via a low-resistance
cable to the earth or water below, where the charge may be safely dissipated.
Lightning rods sometimes possess a short
circuit to the ground
that is interrupted by a thin non-conductor
over which lightning jumps. Ideally, the underground part of the assembly
should reside in a muddy area, or an area that tends to become so during
storms. If the underground cable will resist corrosion
well, it may be covered in salt
to improve its electrical connection with the ground.
In telegraphy
and telephony
a lightning rod is placed where wires enter a structure, preventing damage to
electronic instruments within and ensuring the safety of individuals near
them. Similarly, high-tension
power lines carry a lighter conductor wire over the main power conductors.
This conductor is grounded at various points along the link. Electrical
substations usually have a web of the lighter conductor wires covering the
whole plant.
Considerable material is used in the construction of lightning arrestors,
so it is prudent to work out where a new arrestor will have the greatest
effect. Historical understanding of lightning assumed that each rod protected
a cone
of 45 degrees [1].
This has been found to be unsatisfactory for protecting taller structures, as
it is possible for lightning to strike the side of a building.
A better technique to determine the effect of a new arrestor is called the
rolling sphere technique and was developed by Dr Tibor Horváth. To understand
this requires knowledge of how lightning 'moves'. As the step
leader of a lightning bolt jumps toward the ground, it steps toward the grounded
objects nearest its path. The maximum distance that each step may travel is
called the critical distance and is proportional to the electrical
current. Objects are likely to be struck if they are nearer to the leader than
this critical distance. It is standard practice to approximate the sphere's
radius as 60m near the ground.
Electricity travels along the path of least resistance, so an object
outside the critical distance is unlikely to be struck by the leader if there
is a grounded object within the critical distance. Noting this, locations that
are safe from lightning can be determined by imagining a leader's potential
paths as a sphere
that travels from the cloud to the ground.
For lightning protection it suffices to consider all possible spheres as
they touch potential strike points. To determine which strike points consider
a sphere rolling over the terrain. At each point we are simulating a potential
leader position and where the sphere touches the ground the lightning is most
likely to strike. Points which the sphere cannot roll across and touch are
safest from lightning. Lightning rods should be placed where they will prevent
the sphere from touching a structure.
It is commonly believed, erroneously, that a rod ending in a sharp point at
the peak is the best means to conduct the current
of a lightning strike to the ground. According to field research, a rod with a
rounded or spherical end is better. "Lightning Rod Improvement
Studies" [2]
by Moore et al say:
-
Calculations of the relative strengths of the electric fields above
similarly exposed sharp and blunt rods show that although the fields,
prior to any emissions, are much stronger at the tip of a sharp rod, they
decrease more rapidly with distance. As a result, at a few centimeters
above the tip of a 20-mm-diameter blunt rod, the strength
of the field is greater than that over an otherwise similar, sharper
rod at the same height. Since the field strength at the tip of a sharpened
rod tends to be limited by the easy formation of ions in the surrounding
air, the field strengths over blunt rods can be much stronger than those
at distances greater than 1 cm over sharper ones.
-
The results of this study suggest that moderately blunt metal rods
(with tip height–to–tip radius of curvature ratios of about 680:1) are
better lightning strike receptors than are sharper rods or very blunt ones.
History
Lightning damage has been with humanity since we started building
structures. Early structures made of wood and stone tended to be short and in
valleys and as a result lightning hit rarely. As buildings became taller
lightning became a significant threat. Lightning can damage structures made of
most materials (masonry, wood, concrete and even steel) as the huge currents
involved can heat materials, and especially water to high temperatures causing
fire, loss of strength and explosions from superheated
steam and air.
Europe
The church tower of many European cities, usually the highest structure,
was the building often hit by lightning. Early on, Christian churches tried to
prevent the occurrence of the damaging effects of lightning by prayers.
Priests prayed,
-
temper the destruction of hail and cyclones and the force of tempests
and lightning; check hostile thunders and great winds; and cast down the
spirits of storms and the powers of the air.
Peter Ahlwardts ("Reasonable and Theological Considerations about
Thunder and Lightning", 1745) gave information to individuals seeking
cover from lightning to go anywhere except in or around a church.[3]
United States
In the United
States, the pointed lightning rod conductor, and more accurately the
"lightning attractor", was invented by Benjamin
Franklin as part of his groundbreaking explorations of electricity.
Franklin speculated that, with an iron
rod sharpened to a point at the end,
-
the electrical fire would, I think, be drawn out of a cloud silently,
before it could come near enough to strike [...].
Franklin had speculated about lightning rods for several years before his
reported kite experiment.
This experiment, in fact, took place because he was tired of waiting for
Christ Church in Philadelphia
to be completed so he could place a lighting rod on top of it. There was some
resistance from churches who felt that it was defying divine will to install
these rods. Franklin countered that there is no religious objection to roofs
on buildings to resist precipitation,
so lightning, which he proved to be simply a giant electrical spark, should be
no different.
In the 19th
century the lightning rod became a symbol of American ingenuity and a
decorative motif. Lightning rods were often embellished with ornamental glass
balls[4]
(now prized by collectors) that also served to provide visual sign of a
lightning strike (when the rod is struck the glass ball shatters and falls
off, indicating to the owner which rod got struck and that they should check
it and the grounding wire for damage). The ornamental appeal of these glass
balls has also been incorporated into weather
vanes.
Nikola
Tesla's U.S.
Patent 1,266,175 was an early improvement in lightning protectors. The
patent was granted due to a fault in Franklin's
original theory of operation; the pointed lightning rod actually ionizes the
air around itself, rendering the air conductive, which in turn raises the
probability of a strike. Many years after receiving his patent, in 1919 Dr.
Tesla wrote an article for The
Electrical Experimenter entitled "Famous
Scientific Illusions", in which he explains the logic
of Franklin's pointed lightning rod and discloses his improved method and
apparatus. Despite the publicity, the pointed lightning rod is still
misapplied today.
References
 |
 |
^
C. B. Moore, William Rison, James Mathis, and Graydon Aulich, "Lightning
Rod Improvement Studies". Journal of Applied Meteorology:
Vol. 39, No. 5, pp. 593–609. Langmuir Laboratory for Atmospheric
Research, New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology, Socorro, New
Mexico. April 10, 1999. (lightning rod design)
 |
|
| |
History
Patents
 |
U.S.
Patent 367435 -- Lightning arrestore for the protection of oil
tanks
 |
 |
U.S.
Patent 6474595 - Herman, "Electrical energy
depletion/collection system". November 5, 2002. (Aeronautics,
Lightning arresters and static eliminators; Saftey and protection of
systems and devices, High voltage dissipation (e.g., lightning arrester) )
|
| |
External articles
Have fun. That is the goal of many of the offerings here at ElectricianEducation.com.
|